Intimate Knowing: How To Work With Thinking In Zazen

In our ongoing Vine of Obstacles Zen practice period focussing on the teaching of Keizan Jokin Zenji (1261-1325), a fourth generation master in Japan, we see that a great deal of his teaching simply points to how to do it - Zen practice-awakening.

And Keizan also exudes a particular tone, like a radio frequency, that we are also steeping ourselves in - provisionally, I'd describe it as "friendly luminosity."

For example, how should a practitioner work most skilly with thinking? Keizan (as translated by William M. Bodiford) says,

"Simply know [your thoughts] intimately, analyze them intimately, then temporarily cut them off, sit for a while, and look!"

"Intimately" is such an important element of our Zen way. Here it means closely and personally, and also it has a sense of occurring in the context of family, friends, dharma friends, and all the so-called things of the world.

"Analyze" might seem surprising. In this context it doesn't mean to sit and think about what's coming up in a philosophical or psychoanalytic or dharmababblical (that's a new word :-) manner. With this "analyze" translation, you might think that old Keizan is recommending that you wash mud with mud. Or it might just be the analytical scholarly mind of the translator that's making that recommendation.

Indeed, the primary meaning of the character used here for "analyze," 解, is "to liberate" and also "to loosen, unfasten, untie." As in, untying karmic knots. So rather than analyzing thoughts, intimately unravel them.

"Temporarily," or "for the time being," is also an important detail in these instructions. Thoughts are not the enemy. They are truly also an expression of the one bright pearl. However, thoughts certainly can cloud the heart mind, making a whole and open-hearted embodiment of luminosity unlikely. So for now, cut thoughts off.

The phrase quoted above, then, could be alternately be rendered, "Intimately know, intimately loosen thoughts, and for now cut them off, sit, and look!"